Thursday, June 30, 2022

Suspended Animation

Patrick O’Brian’s sea adventures wouldn’t have worked without some action. Lucky Jack Aubrey has to slip his one ship by five French ships and a land fortress to cut out a valuable prize in harbor, or he has to take his sloop with fourteen guns against a Spanish frigate with thirty-two. (Of course he succeeds in these feats, or he wouldn’t be called Lucky Jack Aubrey.)

But the best parts of the books for me are the long descriptions of daily sea life, when action and danger lie far beyond the horizon. I just reread The Letter of Marque and The Thirteen-Gun Salute – the twelfth and thirteenth installments in the tales of Captain Aubrey and his friend, surgeon, fellow musician, and government agent, Stephen Maturin – and the books are full of a state of nautical suspended animation. HMS Surprise hits the doldrums or simply has days on end of tacking across the Atlantic. In these times, the sailors scrub the decks with their holystones. They play chess. They trade stories. They turn the hour glass and strike the bells. They reef the t’gallant sails. They sing (well, as long as Surprise is a privateer – once reinstated to the Royal Navy, Capt. Aubrey doesn’t go for such frivolity). At one point in one of these books, some character even mentions “suspended animation.”

The frequent tastes of suspended animation in the books don’t all have to do with a sailor’s life, per se. Here and there time stands still as some grand object, literally suspended, brings perspective to time, space, and life. At the end of The Letter of Marque, Stephen dreams of a ride in a hot-air balloon, feeling his cares rolling off his shoulders as he watches clouds go by underneath him. In the middle of The Thirteen-Gun Salute, the best image in the whole series occurs as Stephen sees above him, in a towering wave hovering higher than the ship at the apex of its gigantic undulation, a whale, suspended in the clear, sunlit ocean water.

The best parts of retired life are the boring weeks with no appointments, nothing to do but what Jack’s crew does: read a story or play a song or get all the clocks in the house set to the same time or clean something that hasn’t been ship-shape in a year. (I don’t have any equivalent to reefing t’gallant sails.) Or I might just listen to the murmuring of a million leaves rustling in the gentle summer breeze or drive down the road to the Greenbrier entrance of Great Smoky Mountains National Park and watch the waters of the Little Pigeon River incessantly cascade down the rocks on their way to the ocean Jack Aubrey sailed. But with one thing and another (I don’t need to go into any details), I hadn’t had any boring weeks since the beginning of last July. Maybe I decided to take this angle on O’Brian this year because his images of suspended animation came through my schedule just as all the crises came to resolutions and the blessed boring weeks began again.

Thursday, June 16, 2022

My Refreshing Experience with Chesterton This Year

What can I say about G. K. Chesterton after I’ve written so many posts about him? I’m not going to give you a list of nifty quotations; you can buy whole books of his pithy, twisty aphorisms. I also won’t rehash the story of my discovery last year that I had been on a forty-year quest to rediscover some favorite essays I read in the ’80s only to find I’d been looking for them in the wrong books. (OK, I guess I just rehashed it.) Much more important and pertinent is my need to report my experience with Chesterton this year, without necessarily focusing on the author himself.

I began by dreading my yearly encounter. Between court dates and an earache, I wasn’t sure I had the emotional wherewithal to wade through the topical pieces I had no chance of understanding just to get to the few good offerings. But after getting through January, 1926, and making it to his column for February 13, I found new strength in the peculiar comfort and joy that somehow only GKC can impart. In fact, I remembered that twenty years ago I often read through some Chesterton during stressful times precisely because he made them less stressful.

What is it about Chesterton that serves so well as a specific for my disquietude? It’s not particularly the “paradoxical” turns of phrase that everyone else seems so enamored of. (They’re not paradoxes, for one thing.) It’s the clear logic, the refreshing skewer popping the thin bubbles of modernist thinking. As I think about it, far from being his own so-called paradoxes, it’s Chesterton’s expert ability to show and demolish the actual paradoxes in modernist thinking that calms my nerves.

When a modern person tells you, he says in that February number, that faith kept the Dark Ages dark, that person speaks from ignorance; faith is the only thing that brought light to the early Middle Ages. But wait; there’s more! The person who says that, clearly not getting it from his own digestion of historical fact, has received it from an authority – a teacher or a modern book – and takes it at face value without examining it by the light of evidence. He is, then, exhibiting the very practice he reviles in what he imagines to be the Middle Ages.

A little later in 1926, Chesterton tells me that modern people can’t make customs, only fashions, and he has given me exactly the words and the formula I needed in order to express what I had been thinking lately about the postmodern penchant for tattoos and ear spacers and buzz cuts on one side of the head. He challenges me (successfully, I think) when he points out on November 13 that democracy was originally made for small societies and still works best only when everyone personally knows the leaders they have elected. His even more pointed conclusion: what we have is not a democracy but a plutocracy. (Can anyone deny that Congress is elected less on the principle of “one person, one vote” than on the principle of “one dollar, one vote”?)

At last – I mean literally on the last essay of the year – Chesterton reminded me that things sometimes explode in goodness just when you think they can’t get any better. (They have a way of punching you in the gut just when you think they can’t get any worse, too, but I didn’t suffer that experience this week.) In what will be one of my favorites of the thousands of Chesterton columns I’ve read in my life, he explains to me the poetic devices of old Christmas Carols that make them so good in “appalling” contrast to poetically flaccid hymns like (his example) “There Is a Fountain Filled with Blood.” I won’t say more now, though. I want to save it for December when I write about “The Holly and the Ivy.”

Tuesday, May 31, 2022

Good Stories Make up Good Chapters, Which Make up Good Books

Over the course of forty years or so, I’ve read and reread books on the American Civil War by Shelby Foote and Bruce Catton. For this ten-year reading plan, I wanted to branch out and find some other authors worth visiting over and over. One of my happy discoveries has been Steven E. Woodworth. In rereading just now my post from two years ago on Woodworth’s While God Is Marching On, I was reminded about some disappointing features early in that book. But right now I’m reading his history of the Union Army of the Tennessee, entitled Nothing but Victory, and I’m happy to report that none of the problematic tendencies of the earlier book show up here.

It is odd to read an account focusing on just one of the several armies that the United States deployed in that war; the tightly defined subject matter creates some interesting differences in the way some familiar stories are told. The Battle of Lookout Mountain, for instance (the so-called “Battle Above the Clouds”), is barely mentioned, in just one sentence, having been conducted, as far as the northern forces were concerned, by Joseph Hooker leading the Army of the Cumberland. On the other hand, the accompanying Battle of Missionary Ridge (begun by the Army of the Tennessee, both struggles being part of the greater battle for Chattanooga) is outlined in detail, regiment by regiment. (Regiments make up brigades, which make up divisions, which make up corps, which make up armies.)

Where Woodworth really shines is in the personal stories. I loved reading about the men who scoured Illinois during the summer of 1861 trying to recruit one hundred soldiers each in order to be made captain of the company. (Companies make up regiments, which make up . . . .) Then there were the women and girls who sewed flags for these companies and special hats for the uniformless volunteers to wear and who held parties and public ceremonies in which they bestowed, with eloquent blessings, the precious sewn goods to the departing troops. I’d read often that John McClernand was a political rival to Lincoln whom Lincoln commissioned as a general; Woodworth tells me just how that happened. (It involved McClernand’s help in recruiting in southern Illinois, where many were sypathetic to the seceded states.) I’d read about the Battle of Shiloh before, but I don’t ever remember reading about the crowds of northern civilians who swarmed to the rural Tennessee area after the battle to help the wounded or search for and bury dead loved ones.

Woodworth reads personal journals of soldiers incessantly. I might have expected to read in another book that private George Smith told God that he would serve Him if he survived the siege of Vicksburg. But Woodworth’s reading doesn’t end with the entries from 1865; he tells us that Smith’s journal from fifty years later confirms that he kept his promise. How many pages about sick children and cows bought for five dollars and visits from Aunt Polly did Woodworth have to read through before finding this pertinent detail? Moving from the sublime to the ridiculous, my final example concerns Private Albert Crummell of the 30th Ohio who, in a brief lull in the fighting around Atlanta, made furtive forays into no-man’s land to search for tobacco in the packs of dead rebel soldiers but found one who was, as Miracle Max would say, only mostly dead and who demanded that Crummell carry him to safety in return for the tobacco. Crummell made the trade.

Friday, May 20, 2022

All’s Well that Ends with a Problem?

All’s Well that Ends Well has been known since 1896 as one of Shakespeare’s “problem plays.” The problem, according to some, is that Bertram [spoilers ahead!] displays his love for Helena too suddenly at the end of the play, after four-and-seven-eighths acts of despising her. Here’s how the situation unfolds: Helena is the orphan of a great physician, and she brings a cure to the king of France one day. The cure works, and as a reward, the king gives her any lord she wishes to marry, and Helena chooses Bertram. The offended Bertram weds her according to the sovereign’s orders, but vows never to consummate the marriage. He even runs away to war just to get away from her. But the ever hopeful Helena plays an elaborate ruse on Bertram and then appears at the end to explain everything that has happened, upon which Bertram accepts her.

Some say that Bertram doesn’t really willingly relent at the end but gives in only under coercion. Some say that there must be some missing text that explains the reluctant husband’s sudden change. And I have to admit that the first two times I read this play, I was searching for some explanation for Bertram’s quick conversion, as well. But this time, everything seemed clear. The problem seemed to resolve itself very neatly right in the clear words written on the page. How did I miss this before? How have others missed this?

First, there’s a comic side-plot involving Bertram’s rascally servant named Parolles. Parolles is also the subject of a ruse, and as a result Bertram sees just how unfaithful his servant is. Perhaps this series of events gets our hero thinking about relationships and vows and duty and helps him see things from Helena’s point of view. Second, it is rumored near the end of the play that Helena is dead, and Bertram explicitly admits that he loves her now that he realizes what he has lost. So what’s the problem? How is his change of heart “sudden”? Can I also suggest that Shakespeare didn’t see a problem or else he wouldn’t have given the play the title he did?

Monday, April 25, 2022

The Button

I remember that Robert Dallek’s An Unfinished Life: John F. Kennedy was one of the last books I put on my Third Decade reading plan. I have several presidential biographies on my draft of a Fourth Decade, and I don’t remember what led me to read this one sooner. Maybe I was thinking about Vietnam in comparison to our current military involvement in Asia. Maybe I was thinking about civil rights because of Confederate statues and “fine people on both sides.”

Whatever the reason, it wasn’t that I’m more interested in Kennedy himself than in some of the other U. S. Presidents on my future reading plans (Madison and Eisenhower, for instance). I’ve thought of him as overrated and extremely problematic in that the good he did (or might have done) always has to be taken in the context of his lies about Vietnam. As it turns out, Dallek made Kennedy’s faults look even worse, his virtues even better, and the most amazing parts of his story even more astonishing, and he caused me to reassess the 35th President.

The bad parts first. I found Kennedy’s sense of rich-boy privilege disgusting; as kids, he and his siblings were known to step off a pleasure boat and just throw their coats on the sidewalk in town knowing that someone (they never knew who) would pick them up. The extravagant womanizing started in high school, so it can’t be explained away as caused by a mid-life fear of death. And his willingness to lie to the American public as President just felt like the beginning of a Greek tragedy.

Now for the amazing: Kennedy’s health problems started while he was still a child, and doctors prescribed for him what was then an experimental treatment: steroids. But he didn’t get shots or swallow pills as you or I might: young Jack had to cut a slit in his leg and slip a tablet under the flap in his skin. Sadly, the overdoses of the steroids caused even greater issues later, including his spinal problems. As President, Kennedy was on a crazy cocktail of drugs every day to deal with the constant pain. Dallek doesn’t think the heavy medication affected his performance, but can we really believe that?

And finally the good: Kennedy’s heroism in World War II was not exaggerated, as I had previously thought. After PT 109 was destroyed, Kennedy swam for miles, pulling an injured buddy by gripping the straps of his comrade’s life vest in his teeth. And, wow! did he have to fight his generals to keep the Cuban Missile Crisis from going nuclear. I said that I’ve thought before that all of the good in John Kennedy has to be taken in the context of his lies. But now it seems to me that all of his missteps have to be taken in the context of his insistence that the President alone decides when nuclear weapons will be used. It is a cliché of our times that the President has The Button. But Kennedy made The Button and then took it out of the hands of the people who insisted that nuclear war could be won. This sounds like crazy hyperbole, but I think I was able to enjoy this book only because Kennedy’s restraint during thirteen days in the fall of 1962 left us a world where I and books still exist.

Friday, April 1, 2022

Literary Offenses

I’ve read Mark Twain’s “Fenimore Cooper’s Literary Offenses” many times. Laughed at it, too. Hard. I had read Cooper’s Last of the Mohicans when I was a teenager, and every hilarious invective of Twain’s seemed justified when cast toward the author who had his hero Hawkeye crawl into an Indian camp wearing a bear skin as a disguise without raising suspicion.

But when putting together my reading plan for this third decade, I just felt I had to read some more Cooper, if only because he was such an important figure in the history of American literature. His books established the genre of adventure on the American frontier and enjoyed huge popularity at home and in Europe. So I scheduled The Pathfinder for year 6.

And I’m glad I did! Oh, the book had its problems. The pacing, for instance, seemed strange to my twenty-first-century sensibilities. The first group of main characters takes about 20% of the whole book to get down a river to a settlement. One set of rapids and one Indian ambush would have been enough for me. Later on, the heroine hides in a fort for about 30% of the book.

But the action was exciting (you know, the first one or two times each challenge occurred). The romance was interesting, with Mabel Dunham having a choice between two and possibly three virtuous men of varying personalities. And the Natives were portrayed surprisingly fairly. Some are devious, others are trustworthy. All have a set of mental, ethical, and religious principles distinctly non-European, and the hero – Hawkeye again, although here known only as “The Pathfinder” – repeatedly describes these principles as the Indians’ proper gifts. Mark Twain’s review seemed grossly unjust to me while I was reading The Pathfinder.

But then there was that scene with the bullets in the tree.

Monday, March 14, 2022

OK, I Didn’t Remember

OK, I didn’t remember that D’Arcy proposes to Elizabeth about halfway through Pride and Prejudice. And what a terrible proposal it is! At this point, you can’t say that Elizabeth’s view of the man is tainted by prejudice: he really is a jerk here, and she justly turns him down.

And, OK, so I didn’t remember that D’Arcy was such a jerk at first! In my memory, D’Arcy had legitimate concerns about some of the people in Elizabeth’s neighborhood, concerns about which, however, he was unable to speak, and so Elizabeth mistook his reticence for coldness and pride. But, no, he’s something of a misanthrope at first. So why do so many women see him as the ultimate romantic male character in fiction? Well, partly because he looks so good once he cleans up at the end. But also because from the first he declares that his ideal woman uses her mind and reads, thus complementing and justifying every girl who reads the book.

OK, so I didn’t remember that Elizabeth shows her intellect and strength at the end of the book by being so cheeky! Her conversation with Lady de Burgh, who informs Elizabeth that she has heard that she (Elizabeth) and D’Arcy are to be married, is hilarious and amazing. Females are supposed to be quiet . . . unless they have money, but Elizabeth refuses to take any of Lady de Burgh’s bait and professes her independence of body, mind, and will loudly and forcefully. And then that ending! Where Elizabeth alone of everyone he has ever known dares to tease D’Arcy. She knows more than even he himself knows that he will love this treatment because it shows a razing of the artificial walls of their code-bound society, a demolition necessary before any lasting, satisfying, spiritual intimacy is possible.

This I remember: Jane Austen never gets old.