After watching an interesting but slightly confusing movie called Anonymous, I started reading a book on a topic I’ve wanted to know more about for a long time: the authorship of Shakespeare. John Michell’s Who Wrote Shakespeare? takes a neutral approach, tracing the history of the question and laying out the arguments for each of the candidates. Since most of the negative arguments have elements of rationality while most of the positive arguments smack of the kind of theory that might come out of a shed covered with paper and criss-crossed with a hundred taut strands of red yarn, Michell almost has me convinced that no one could have written the famous plays and poems. And yet there they are, and my only other option – the infinite number of monkeys with their infinite number of typewriters – has yet to be found. So I suppose some human or humans did actually write them.
In a nutshell, the case against the actor from Stratford-upon-Avon rests on the seeming unlikelihood that a man from a country town with a country school, a man whose father and daughter were illiterate, could have written the most elegant, complex, moving, creative, beautiful expressions in the history of the English language – perhaps of any language. To expand just a bit, anti-Stratfordians ask how the country rube, even going to London for a few years to act on stage, could have known about court life, hunting, falconry, mythology, music, seamanship, the law, horticulture, and fifty other esoteric subjects. Several answers come to mind. (1) He read about all these topics in books and, with his inarguably brilliant mind, became fluent with their terms and ideas. (2) Some of these topics – hunting, law, and horticulture, for instance – don’t seem surprising at all for a landowner from a rural town. (3) Brilliant minds can come from small towns. (4) Brilliant minds generally find a way to succeed in spite of their schooling.
But I also wonder just how knowledgeable Shakespeare actually was on all these topics. I can only speak with any certainty about music, and there he uses enough vocabulary to show that he had met with music theory, but doesn’t really say enough to be either accurate or inaccurate. Mercutio, for instance, uses musical terminology when complaining that Tybalt fights tepidly: “He fights as you sing pricksong – keeps time, distance, and proportion; rests me his minim rest, one, two, and the third in your bosom!” I can’t tell from this whether Shakespeare could be called an expert in music, whether, for instance, he could have taught a beginning class competently. But I have no doubt he read a book and picked up terminology that satisfied his interest in “words, words, words.” After all, did he really need to know what pricksong was in order to see the potential for a ribald pun in the term? “Time, distance, and proportion” could represent a faulty memory of the trio of metrical terms from Renaissance music theory: mode, time, and prolation. But even if that’s true, I don’t know if I should ascribe the mistake to Shakespeare or to Mercutio. Maybe Shakespeare knew what he was talking about, but he certainly didn’t prove it. How many of the Bard’s allusions to other subjects sound like expert knowledge to me without truly indicating any more mastery than Mercutio does of music?
Then, too, I also wonder, after all the questions of how a laborer’s son could have depicted royalty so faithfully, how the Earl of Oxford or Sir Francis Bacon or any of the other aristocrats put forth as the “true” author could have depicted lower-class patter so well. Baconians ask: How did the man from Stratford know how to write the lines of Henry VIII? But I haven’t yet read that anyone asks the Baconians: How did the Lord Chancellor of England know how to write the lines of Mistress Quickly?
Saturday, August 17, 2013
Was Shakespeare Shakespeare?
Labels:
Francis Bacon,
John Michell,
William Shakespeare
Tuesday, August 13, 2013
Three Years Ago
It’s hard for me to believe that I’ve been writing this blog for three years now, but it’s true. Three hundred forty-seven posts have preceded this one. I’ve reached twenty thousand views and average over eight hundred a month. The blog keeps me accountable for keeping up with my plan and focuses my thinking: I definitely get more out of what I read knowing that I’ll report my thoughts to strangers around the world. (17% of the hits come from Russia.)
Here are some of my favorite posts from the last year:
Here are some of my favorite posts from the last year:
The Dramatic Death of Julius CaesarI posted similar lists in August of 2011 and August of 2012. I don’t think I quite matched the quality of some of those earlier pieces, but I’m still very happy with these. I’m grateful for my readers, and I’ll try to stick with the blog and with you for another three years. May all the books we read in that time be great!
On the Border of Love
Re: My Hackles
Charles Williams See Reality, Part I
Charles Williams See Reality, Part II
Charles Williams See Reality, Part III
Monarchs and Memories
The Beauty of Guilt
Shelley's "A Summer Evening Churchyard"
The Probability of Peirce
Who Talks Like Shakespeare?
Saturday, August 10, 2013
A Discovery
I’ve made a discovery. My discovery doesn’t have anything like the weight of the benzene circle or the Rosetta Stone’s hieroglyphics. I can’t even claim a victory on the order of Michael Ward’s for uncovering the secret organization to The Chronicles of Narnia. But my discovery does have something to do with C. S. Lewis, specifically with his “Lord, Liar, Lunatic” trilemma.
In book II, chapter 3 of Mere Christianity, Lewis offers one version of the argument:
The argument possesses great strength and has influenced Charles Colson, Ronald Reagan, and Bono. But it isn’t airtight. As Peter Kreeft points out (somewhere), a fourth option that isn’t moot exists: Jesus as Legend. The Lord, Liar, Lunatic argument doesn’t deal with the issue of whether Jesus actually said the things recorded in the first five books of the New Testament. I’ve wondered, too, if the meta-argument doesn’t need to include the possibility of Jesus as Lyric Poet. (It’s two words, I know, but it’s the best I can do while still starting with an L.) Maybe Jesus spoke figuratively, delivering a truth, but one that didn’t correspond literally with the meaning on the surface of the words. In the words of Poet Jack Gilbert:
Prof. Lewis’s version, though, involves only three options, and I believe I’ve discovered an important source. Wikipedia reports a number of nineteenth-century expositions of the trilemma, and the author of Mere Christianity may well have known about and read all of them. But I’ve found an interesting footnote in a book I’m sure Lewis read that may well have served as the fillip (two chances to use that word in one week!) to Lewis’s thinking about this important exercise of apologetics. In chapter XI of The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, Gibbon says in footnote 63:
In book II, chapter 3 of Mere Christianity, Lewis offers one version of the argument:
A man who was merely a man and said the sort of things Jesus said would not be a great moral teacher. He would either be a lunatic — on the level with the man who says he is a poached egg — or else he would be the Devil of Hell. You must make your choice. Either this man was, and is, the Son of God, or else a madman or something worse.The reasoning actually represents a specific case of a more general argument. Anyone making any claim either (A) speaks the truth or (B) doesn’t. If the claim is not true, either (B1) the speaker knows it is not true, or (B2) he doesn’t. Three possibilities. When the claim is trivial – say someone claims to have enough money in her purse to buy lunch – B1 constitutes mild dissembling and B2 represents a sincere mistake in judgment. When the claim, though, declares the speaker’s equality with God, scenario B1 involves a very bad lie indeed, and scenario B2 changes from the statement of a sincerely mistaken person to the ravings of a lunatic. (The claim of equality with God also makes totally moot a trivial but logical fourth possibility: that the speaker tells the truth but doesn’t really know it. Surely God knows that He is God.) In the case of Jesus, the exemplary nature of his moral teaching and life rule out B1 (Liar) and B2 (Lunatic) and leave us only A: He is Lord.
The argument possesses great strength and has influenced Charles Colson, Ronald Reagan, and Bono. But it isn’t airtight. As Peter Kreeft points out (somewhere), a fourth option that isn’t moot exists: Jesus as Legend. The Lord, Liar, Lunatic argument doesn’t deal with the issue of whether Jesus actually said the things recorded in the first five books of the New Testament. I’ve wondered, too, if the meta-argument doesn’t need to include the possibility of Jesus as Lyric Poet. (It’s two words, I know, but it’s the best I can do while still starting with an L.) Maybe Jesus spoke figuratively, delivering a truth, but one that didn’t correspond literally with the meaning on the surface of the words. In the words of Poet Jack Gilbert:
Poetry is a kind of lying,Of course, I have reasons not to pick either Door No. 4 or Door No. 5. I have reasons to believe the words of the New Testament; if it says that Jesus said, “I am the Way, the Truth, and the Life” and “Before Abraham was, I am,” then I believe that Jesus said these things. And I can’t see Jesus accepting the tortures of his trial and execution if He had meant his words only poetically. But still, the argument seems a pentalemma at least.
necessarily. To profit the poet
or beauty. But also in
that truth may be told only so.
Prof. Lewis’s version, though, involves only three options, and I believe I’ve discovered an important source. Wikipedia reports a number of nineteenth-century expositions of the trilemma, and the author of Mere Christianity may well have known about and read all of them. But I’ve found an interesting footnote in a book I’m sure Lewis read that may well have served as the fillip (two chances to use that word in one week!) to Lewis’s thinking about this important exercise of apologetics. In chapter XI of The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, Gibbon says in footnote 63:
Apollonius of Tyana was born about the same time as that of Jesus Christ. His life (that of the former) is related in so fabulous a manner by his disciples, that we are at a loss to discover whether he was a sage, an imposter, or a fanatic.Gibbon mentions Jesus Christ ostensibly only to establish an historical timeframe. Then he clarifies, with tongue in cheek I think, that the rest of the footnote has nothing to do with Jesus. But surely he suggests that it does; if Jesus’ disciples had not also recorded his life in a “fabulous” manner, Gibbon wouldn’t have needed to clarify. Neither would he have needed a clarification had he simply dated the birth of Apollonius by a numbered year. No, Gibbon sees the connection, and in the not-so-hidden parallel, he acknowledges three possible ways to view the central Character of the Gospels. Those three ways are almost exactly those of Lewis’s Lord, Liar, Lunatic argument. “Imposter” lines up neatly with “Liar,” “Fanatic” with “Lunatic.” But again, the specific nature of Jesus’ claims about Himself sharpens the horns of the trilemma: a Man saying truthfully, “No one comes to the Father but by Me,” is no mere sage.
Labels:
C. S. Lewis,
Edward Gibbon,
Jack Gilbert,
Michael Ward,
Peter Kreeft
Thursday, August 8, 2013
More Lessons from Gibbon
A couple of posts back, I praised Edward Gibbon for interspersing his account of emperors and legions with lessons: general patterns that he observes, interpretations of events based on his knowledge of human nature, and even moral lessons. The reader’s goal should be not simply to learn history but to learn from history, and Gibbon does his best to get his readers started on that project.
In the second chapter of The Decline and Fall he offers an observation on economics. “It might,” he begins, “perhaps be more conducive to the virtue, as well as happiness, of mankind, if all possessed the necessities, and none of the superfluities, of life. But in the present imperfect condition of society, luxury, though it may proceed from vice or folly, seems to be the only means that can correct the unequal distribution of property.” Property owners want to improve the pleasantries of their lives with the products of mechanics and artisans, so mechanics and artisans get money. And the denarii that flow to the city of Rome as tax from the provinces flow back again in payment for their manufactures. Any Economics 101 class covers the circulation of wealth, but how many freshman textbooks observe that mankind might be happier if everyone had what they needed and no more?
In chapter III, again looking out for the greater happiness of our race, Gibbon draws another distinction between the ideal and the actual. The clergy, he says, might be expected to stand up for the rights of the people against a tyrant. But in actuality, they tend to side with the king. Therefore, “a martial nobility and stubborn commons, possessed of arms, tenacious of property, and collected into constitutional assemblies, form the only balance capable of preserving a free constitution against enterprises of an aspiring prince.” (He almost said “a well regulated militia.”)
My favorite among the lessons on life comes in the fifth chapter:
In the second chapter of The Decline and Fall he offers an observation on economics. “It might,” he begins, “perhaps be more conducive to the virtue, as well as happiness, of mankind, if all possessed the necessities, and none of the superfluities, of life. But in the present imperfect condition of society, luxury, though it may proceed from vice or folly, seems to be the only means that can correct the unequal distribution of property.” Property owners want to improve the pleasantries of their lives with the products of mechanics and artisans, so mechanics and artisans get money. And the denarii that flow to the city of Rome as tax from the provinces flow back again in payment for their manufactures. Any Economics 101 class covers the circulation of wealth, but how many freshman textbooks observe that mankind might be happier if everyone had what they needed and no more?
In chapter III, again looking out for the greater happiness of our race, Gibbon draws another distinction between the ideal and the actual. The clergy, he says, might be expected to stand up for the rights of the people against a tyrant. But in actuality, they tend to side with the king. Therefore, “a martial nobility and stubborn commons, possessed of arms, tenacious of property, and collected into constitutional assemblies, form the only balance capable of preserving a free constitution against enterprises of an aspiring prince.” (He almost said “a well regulated militia.”)
My favorite among the lessons on life comes in the fifth chapter:
The true interest of an absolute monarch generally coincides with that of his people. Their numbers, their wealth, their order, and their security, are the best and only foundations of his real greatness; and were he totally devoid of virtue, prudence might supply its place, and would dictate the same rule of conduct.Substitute “director” or “dean” for “monarch,” and I’ve said the same thing many times. Okay, my lamentation has gone, so the person I work for is self-centered and self-serving. Why does he have to treat us so poorly? Our free, productive activity, our “order and security,” offer the surest way for him to keep making two to three times as much as the rest of us. He doesn’t even have to be good: if he were only smart, he’d treat us better. Please take all the credit for what I do! Of course, you’ll have to understand what I do and appreciate its value in order to brag about it. And then you’ll have to make sure I have the time and resources to do it well. But after that, please, by all means, take all the credit and enjoy that corner office suite for many years to come!
Tuesday, August 6, 2013
Vocabulary from Casterbridge
Over the last few weeks, my wife and I and our friends the Fixes have been watching a course on the English language from the Teaching Company. I highly recommend this DVD series. The professor, Anne Curzan of the University of Michigan, explains her interesting material in a clear and entertaining manner, and we all look forward to the chance to watch the next couple of lessons. So far we’ve heard about prescriptive and descriptive rules, the history of dictionaries, how meanings change over time, word borrowings, the creation of new words, who decides what is and isn’t a word, and problems of pronunciation. Did you know that our era of American history is witness to the Northern Cities Vowel Shift?
Part of the fascination of this subject comes from its seeming familiarity. Anyone reading this blog post uses English every day, probably without having to think about it much. But then you learn that the word clue originally meant a ball of yarn, or that we tend to pronounce a ‘p’ before the last letter of dreamt, and you start to wonder how well you know the language after all. One mark of knowledge of a language is the number of words one knows. But it turns out that even something as conceptually simple as counting becomes quite tricky in practice. Do run and runs count as two words? How about ran? Running? Runny? Does the person who knows the meanings of run, down, and run-down know two words or three? But even if I can’t put a definitive number on the size of my vocabulary, one thing I know, thanks to Prof. Curzan, is that my active vocabulary is smaller than my passive vocabulary. In other words, I recognize and understand a lot more words than I use.
I ended up disappointed in The Mayor of Casterbridge, mostly because I couldn’t find anyone to root for. The narrative makes no judgments on actions, so what I would call right actions appear just as much the product of momentary whimsy as the evil or unwise actions. People fall in love, redirect their affections, become widowed, remarry, sell their spouses, run away from spouses, and let spouses think they’re dead with little drama. Sometimes these events occur with hardly a mention. In the middle of the book, Elizabeth-Jane falls for Daniel and suffers disappointment when, after giving her some promising attention, he marries Lucetta instead. But Lucetta dies, and a few pages later, Daniel and Elizabeth-Jane are friends again. Another quick time shift to a year later, and they’re married. No discussion, no apologies, no doubts about Daniel’s commitment.
But Hardy’s language has a rich poetic texture, and I reveled in the vocabulary as I finished MoC. Determined now to transfer some of my passive vocabulary into my active vocabulary, I paid special attention to words that I knew but had perhaps never used myself: words like maelstrom, abjure, and discomfiture. The next time I have anything to say about something related to Canada, I’m going to call it hyperborean. Rather than calling a circumstance promising, I’ll try next time to refer to it as propitious. Developing new vocabulary, though, isn’t just a matter of using unusual synonyms; some words stand for complex situations that I might not mention (or even notice!) without knowledge of the word. For instance, an invidious plan or statement or policy or action isn’t just really bad. It provokes displeasure, disapproval, or envy in others. Other candidates for my active vocabulary include inveterate, engender, dissipate, disquietude, and fillip. Okay, I didn’t know the last one at all, so it’s shooting straight to the majors without any time in the passive-vocabulary league. Watching the course was just the fillip I needed.
I can’t close this post on vocabulary from The Mayor of Casterbridge without pointing out two special words appearing closely together within one paragraph in chapter 20. At this point in the story, Elizabeth-Jane has a vocabulary project of her own: to quit using rural words in order to sound more educated. So she purposes to stop saying dumbledore for bumblebee and to say she has suffered from indigestion rather than that she was hag-rid. Now we know where J. K. Rowling got some of her vocabulary!
Part of the fascination of this subject comes from its seeming familiarity. Anyone reading this blog post uses English every day, probably without having to think about it much. But then you learn that the word clue originally meant a ball of yarn, or that we tend to pronounce a ‘p’ before the last letter of dreamt, and you start to wonder how well you know the language after all. One mark of knowledge of a language is the number of words one knows. But it turns out that even something as conceptually simple as counting becomes quite tricky in practice. Do run and runs count as two words? How about ran? Running? Runny? Does the person who knows the meanings of run, down, and run-down know two words or three? But even if I can’t put a definitive number on the size of my vocabulary, one thing I know, thanks to Prof. Curzan, is that my active vocabulary is smaller than my passive vocabulary. In other words, I recognize and understand a lot more words than I use.
I ended up disappointed in The Mayor of Casterbridge, mostly because I couldn’t find anyone to root for. The narrative makes no judgments on actions, so what I would call right actions appear just as much the product of momentary whimsy as the evil or unwise actions. People fall in love, redirect their affections, become widowed, remarry, sell their spouses, run away from spouses, and let spouses think they’re dead with little drama. Sometimes these events occur with hardly a mention. In the middle of the book, Elizabeth-Jane falls for Daniel and suffers disappointment when, after giving her some promising attention, he marries Lucetta instead. But Lucetta dies, and a few pages later, Daniel and Elizabeth-Jane are friends again. Another quick time shift to a year later, and they’re married. No discussion, no apologies, no doubts about Daniel’s commitment.
But Hardy’s language has a rich poetic texture, and I reveled in the vocabulary as I finished MoC. Determined now to transfer some of my passive vocabulary into my active vocabulary, I paid special attention to words that I knew but had perhaps never used myself: words like maelstrom, abjure, and discomfiture. The next time I have anything to say about something related to Canada, I’m going to call it hyperborean. Rather than calling a circumstance promising, I’ll try next time to refer to it as propitious. Developing new vocabulary, though, isn’t just a matter of using unusual synonyms; some words stand for complex situations that I might not mention (or even notice!) without knowledge of the word. For instance, an invidious plan or statement or policy or action isn’t just really bad. It provokes displeasure, disapproval, or envy in others. Other candidates for my active vocabulary include inveterate, engender, dissipate, disquietude, and fillip. Okay, I didn’t know the last one at all, so it’s shooting straight to the majors without any time in the passive-vocabulary league. Watching the course was just the fillip I needed.
I can’t close this post on vocabulary from The Mayor of Casterbridge without pointing out two special words appearing closely together within one paragraph in chapter 20. At this point in the story, Elizabeth-Jane has a vocabulary project of her own: to quit using rural words in order to sound more educated. So she purposes to stop saying dumbledore for bumblebee and to say she has suffered from indigestion rather than that she was hag-rid. Now we know where J. K. Rowling got some of her vocabulary!
Wednesday, July 31, 2013
Why Did Rome Fall?
Don’t expect the definitive answer to that one! I can only tell you today about the causes Edward Gibbon assigns to history’s favorite catastrophe. In fact, I can really only report on the causes Gibbon has mentioned in the pages I’ve read. His monumental classic, The Decline and Fall of the Roman Empire, encompasses 4,000 to 5,000 pages in unabridged print editions, pages containing altogether over a million and a half words. Since, according to manybooks.net, War and Peace comes to only 562,579 words, Gibbon’s history is nearly three times as long as what’s proverbially considered fiction’s lengthiest achievement. I’ve read about 7% of those 5,000 pages by now – a mere 100,000 words. So, no, I don’t have the definitive answer. But I have the beginnings of one.
Along the way of recounting the saga of crowns and conflicts, Gibbon takes the opportunity to deliver several lessons on life, a charming habit sadly left unindulged by many modern historians (and most music historians). Just yesterday, for instance, in a section devoted to the third-century emperor Decius’ sincere attempt to reestablish the office of censor, I read this: “A censor may maintain, he can never restore, the morals of a state.” (I love the Latin convention of linking sentences by a shared grammatical object and then leaving that object unstated in the first clause. And I love seeing the idiom find its way into Gibbon’s style.) In other words, national rectitude must be popular; it can’t simply be decreed.
Some of Gibbon’s lessons come from his reflection on the different levels of culture and education that he finds in the various societies taking part in his story. “The use of letters,” he concludes, “is the principle circumstance that distinguishes a civilized people from a herd of savages incapable of knowledge or reflection.” It might be guessed that Gibbon would not have included “plz” or “lmao” in his conception of a civilizing use of letters. Again with the Goths in mind, Gibbon observes that money “is the most universal incitement, iron the most powerful instrument, of human industry.” In other words, civilization depends partly on the metals the ground offers to its inhabitants. I once read a high-school American history text written around 1900 that began by acknowledging the propitious abundance and variety of natural resources afforded by the North American continent. By comparison, the high-school history text I actually read in high school started with explorers; in other words, its (hidden) lesson was that people can take all the credit for their successes.
As for The Lesson that his title promises, Gibbon actually cites an exact moment at which the decline began. After the death of Septimius Severus in 211, his son Caracalla paid the Praetorian Guard an exorbitant sum to secure his accession to the imperial throne. After this, Gibbon explains, the Guard and the legions who sometimes competed with them in the game of emperor-making, came to expect only riches from their Commander-in-Chief rather than discipline. And once a nation’s fighting force obtains a sense of entitlement, it gains political power, making the Senate weak, and loses military power, making the neighbors hungry.
Along the way of recounting the saga of crowns and conflicts, Gibbon takes the opportunity to deliver several lessons on life, a charming habit sadly left unindulged by many modern historians (and most music historians). Just yesterday, for instance, in a section devoted to the third-century emperor Decius’ sincere attempt to reestablish the office of censor, I read this: “A censor may maintain, he can never restore, the morals of a state.” (I love the Latin convention of linking sentences by a shared grammatical object and then leaving that object unstated in the first clause. And I love seeing the idiom find its way into Gibbon’s style.) In other words, national rectitude must be popular; it can’t simply be decreed.
Some of Gibbon’s lessons come from his reflection on the different levels of culture and education that he finds in the various societies taking part in his story. “The use of letters,” he concludes, “is the principle circumstance that distinguishes a civilized people from a herd of savages incapable of knowledge or reflection.” It might be guessed that Gibbon would not have included “plz” or “lmao” in his conception of a civilizing use of letters. Again with the Goths in mind, Gibbon observes that money “is the most universal incitement, iron the most powerful instrument, of human industry.” In other words, civilization depends partly on the metals the ground offers to its inhabitants. I once read a high-school American history text written around 1900 that began by acknowledging the propitious abundance and variety of natural resources afforded by the North American continent. By comparison, the high-school history text I actually read in high school started with explorers; in other words, its (hidden) lesson was that people can take all the credit for their successes.
As for The Lesson that his title promises, Gibbon actually cites an exact moment at which the decline began. After the death of Septimius Severus in 211, his son Caracalla paid the Praetorian Guard an exorbitant sum to secure his accession to the imperial throne. After this, Gibbon explains, the Guard and the legions who sometimes competed with them in the game of emperor-making, came to expect only riches from their Commander-in-Chief rather than discipline. And once a nation’s fighting force obtains a sense of entitlement, it gains political power, making the Senate weak, and loses military power, making the neighbors hungry.
Friday, July 26, 2013
Far Frae Home
A little over a year ago in this blog, I posted about Prof. Jane Vogel’s view of Thomas Hardy. In short, she says that Hardy’s relationship with Christianity was that of a man who loved and longed for a religion he thought was not true. And in reading several of his poems last year, I found traces of that sentiment everywhere I looked. Hardy packed those lyrics with melancholy regret that the values and ideas of the Christian religion were (as far as he could see) not true, that the beauties and sentiments of the faith didn’t ultimately point to anything. Hardy, it seemed to me, pined for a home he believed nonexistent.
His novel The Mayor of Casterbridge picks up right where the poems left off. I’ve read about a third of it now, and I’ve already encountered the word “melancholy” several times. People are melancholy. Locations are melancholy. Melodies are melancholy. One of the main characters (and in my mind the most interesting character to this point), the Scotsman Daniel Farfrae, carries melancholy with him everywhere he goes in the form of his name. “Frae” is Scots dialect for “from,” and in the southern region of Wessex, where the novel takes place, Daniel finds himself far frae Scotland indeed.
In an early scene, he stops at one of the town’s inns and sings a song about his homeland that enraptures all the Englishmen present. They’ve never heard anyone sing about longing for home before, says one, and the beautiful effect surprises them. Another says that he wishes southern England had flowers and lasses so bonnie that he could sing about his own home in the same way. That arresting idea first made me wonder if Daniel’s song and memory hadn’t slightly exaggerated the winsomeness of Scottish girls and their bouquets. But I ended up thinking that that second listener’s view encapsulates Hardy’s entire doleful outlook: the fictional character can’t help but respond to the powerful images and emotions of the song, just as Hardy must admit to the aesthetic charms of the Church, yet they both lament over the futile emptiness of the message.
But that character has in fact (well, in the facts of the imaginary world of the novel, anyway) seen lovely young women and fair vistas: Hardy explicitly describes them. In presenting his melancholy philosophy by symbol and allusion, Hardy, it seems, can’t help using analogies in which desires have actual objects. The melancholy song works because Scotland truly does have beautiful girls and beautiful flowers. The novel’s melancholy scene at a ruined Roman amphitheater works because an empire based on the banks of the Tiber really did reach to the isle of Albion. Why did Hardy suppose – and why should his readers suppose – that the melancholy scenes at churches are any different, that they don’t have any foundation in reality? As C. S. Lewis argued, the existence of hunger reliably indicates the existence of bread, even if it makes no promise that any given hungry person will receive any.
I don’t mean to condemn either Hardy or his writing because of all this, though. Quite to the contrary, his (in my experience) unique position makes for stirring stories and powerful poetry. And, as C. S. Lewis once again argued, this time in reference to his beloved heroes of Nordic myth, one has to admire the virtues of anyone who will continue to champion truth, goodness, and beauty even in the belief that these excellencies won’t win out against chaos in the end.
His novel The Mayor of Casterbridge picks up right where the poems left off. I’ve read about a third of it now, and I’ve already encountered the word “melancholy” several times. People are melancholy. Locations are melancholy. Melodies are melancholy. One of the main characters (and in my mind the most interesting character to this point), the Scotsman Daniel Farfrae, carries melancholy with him everywhere he goes in the form of his name. “Frae” is Scots dialect for “from,” and in the southern region of Wessex, where the novel takes place, Daniel finds himself far frae Scotland indeed.
In an early scene, he stops at one of the town’s inns and sings a song about his homeland that enraptures all the Englishmen present. They’ve never heard anyone sing about longing for home before, says one, and the beautiful effect surprises them. Another says that he wishes southern England had flowers and lasses so bonnie that he could sing about his own home in the same way. That arresting idea first made me wonder if Daniel’s song and memory hadn’t slightly exaggerated the winsomeness of Scottish girls and their bouquets. But I ended up thinking that that second listener’s view encapsulates Hardy’s entire doleful outlook: the fictional character can’t help but respond to the powerful images and emotions of the song, just as Hardy must admit to the aesthetic charms of the Church, yet they both lament over the futile emptiness of the message.
But that character has in fact (well, in the facts of the imaginary world of the novel, anyway) seen lovely young women and fair vistas: Hardy explicitly describes them. In presenting his melancholy philosophy by symbol and allusion, Hardy, it seems, can’t help using analogies in which desires have actual objects. The melancholy song works because Scotland truly does have beautiful girls and beautiful flowers. The novel’s melancholy scene at a ruined Roman amphitheater works because an empire based on the banks of the Tiber really did reach to the isle of Albion. Why did Hardy suppose – and why should his readers suppose – that the melancholy scenes at churches are any different, that they don’t have any foundation in reality? As C. S. Lewis argued, the existence of hunger reliably indicates the existence of bread, even if it makes no promise that any given hungry person will receive any.
I don’t mean to condemn either Hardy or his writing because of all this, though. Quite to the contrary, his (in my experience) unique position makes for stirring stories and powerful poetry. And, as C. S. Lewis once again argued, this time in reference to his beloved heroes of Nordic myth, one has to admire the virtues of anyone who will continue to champion truth, goodness, and beauty even in the belief that these excellencies won’t win out against chaos in the end.
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)