I find it very difficult to put a distinguishing label on my Christian faith. I pray frequently for the holy catholic and apostolic Church, but I’m not a Catholic with a capital C. I recite the Apostles’ Creed and Nicene Creed with full sincerity, so I trust that my beliefs are orthodox; but I’m not Orthodox with a capital O. The term “Protestant” probably best conveys the right idea to someone about my faith, but I’m not protesting anything. I think Paul warns us against labels in I Corinthians 1, but I’m only one against about two billion Christians who seem comfortable with labels, so I accept my eccentricity.
Perhaps rather than finding a single word to stamp me with, it would paint a clearer picture for me to say that while I’m not a Roman Catholic, I love Thomas Aquinas. I look forward to reading him for about a month each year, and every time, I draw tremendous amounts of enlightenment and encouragement from him. He’s not perfect, though. His method of framing every issue in a yes-and-no question, for instance, doesn’t always work: his answer is frequently some version of “It depends.” More importantly, I just don’t think he’s always right. Not holding any formal obligation to the Papacy, I don’t have any obligation to believe everything this Doctor of the Church says. Still, after about fifteen ample yearly samples of the Summa Theologica, I’ve found very little I couldn’t imagine myself conceivably agreeing with. Until now.
This year, I’ve begun the section on the theological virtues: Faith, Hope, and Charity. At the end of the long part on faith, Thomas treats vices opposed to faith: unbelief, heresy, and apostasy. And in the part on heresy, he says that after warning a person two or three times who has previously declared allegiance to Christ but now refuses to agree with approved doctrine, the Church may rightfully put that person to death. It seems to come out of the blue (or possibly the black). His method normally sets up laboriously and meticulously every supporting point that he plans to make use of eight-hundred pages down the road. Then here suddenly, there’s not just a little wacky confusion of truth and culture that we can excuse with a smile, but rationalization for a horrifying part of history without any logical build-up. He cites Titus 3:10-11 as support, but that verse says to avoid the entrenched heretic, not to kill him.
I had a Catholic friend once who spent a lot of time with me talking about matters of faith, Christian history, and biblical interpretation. We had a good time. We ate meals together. We traveled to conferences together. But I discovered ultimately that his relationship with me was founded entirely on a unidirectional agenda. He told me I was separated from my true home, from my Mother, and that he was trying to make me realize how much I wanted to enter into the communion of the Roman Catholic Church. His statement that I was not a member of the Body of Christ but rather a fly hovering around the Body didn’t help entice me at all.
Eventually this friend asked me point-blank if I would become Catholic (with a capital C), and I said, no. Then he asked if (a) I was convinced and just didn’t want to submit to the truth or (b) I remained unconvinced. My answer to him filled in box (b) in his head. I never had another meal with him. He lost all interest in me. I think I was his project, and he realized that he had failed. He had never met a Protestant who liked Aquinas, so I think he felt a lot of hope in the beginning. I guess I ended up wasting a lot of his time.
I thought about him a lot reading these passages on unbelief and heresy. And now I’m reinterpreting his final multiple-choice question and realizing that had I given him answer (a), it may have earned me a new label: heretic. As melodramatic as this sounds, I wonder now if he was trying to ascertain whether I deserved execution.
Wednesday, June 12, 2013
Sunday, June 9, 2013
The Rain of Death
Death pervades Wendell Berry’s A Place on Earth. Old people die. Young soldiers die. Daughters die. Characters talk about it. Characters dread it. The preacher, Brother Piston, tries to console surviving family members after a loved one dies.
But the novel doesn’t treat death as altogether bad. Old Jack Beechum, for instance accepts his inevitable death calmly: “He speaks of the approach of his own death as much as a matter of fact as he speaks of the approach of Tuesday.” His acquiescence probably comes partly from his understanding that death may be a means to an end. He hates to see boys from his town die in war, but, he reasons, “It may be necessary to use up the lives of young men . . . . A choice has to be made between terrible sacrifice and terrible defeat.”
Other characters and circumstances show that death can be a price worth paying for a greater good. Sometimes the lesson somes out symbolically, even allegorically. Uncle Stanley Gibbs digs graves among his other duties at the church. Or has dug them until lately. He can still use the shovel but finds it hard these days to move his old knees enough to get out of the hole once he digs it. The effects of impending death take away his livelihood and literally put him in an early grave. So he asks Jayber Crow, a character who has thought he has no purpose, to take over that part of his job. Jayber finds that for the first time he has a plan, that he possesses “not only a life, but a death.” And Uncle Stanley, now more appreciative than ever of the job he almost lost, discovers that what he gave up has come back. “It is a resurrection. He thought he was a goner, but now his life is twice as abundant as before.”
The novel is told in the present tense, and this, too, plays a symbolic role in the book’s lesson of life, death, and resurrection, of loss and hope. Virgil Feltner has been reported missing in action. The narrator tells us: “The news has gone its rounds among the gathering places, and has quietly set the young man’s life into the past tense of the town’s consciousness. . . . To speak of him in the present tense becomes the private observance of his family.” Burley Coulter expands on the notion of family observance of death in a letter to his nephew Nat, also away at war: “We don’t rest in peace. The life of a good man who has died belongs to the people who cared about him.” Put it all together, and it seems to say that Wendell Berry sees his characters as virtual family and cares about them too much to speak of them in the past tense. I reported a few days ago that I sensed constant hope in the book, and now I see why.
Rain also pervades A Place on Earth. Like death, it hinders people’s movements. It tests their patience. It tests their works (as when young Virgil plows his first field incorrectly). And the connection between rain and death solidifies when a flash flood caused by the inexorable rain carries away a young girl. And so these parallels reinforce the view that death, just like rain, is both bad and good. The rain that caused the river to rise also brings new life out of the fields each spring. And the same death that puts lost soldiers into the past tense brings resurrection.
But the novel doesn’t treat death as altogether bad. Old Jack Beechum, for instance accepts his inevitable death calmly: “He speaks of the approach of his own death as much as a matter of fact as he speaks of the approach of Tuesday.” His acquiescence probably comes partly from his understanding that death may be a means to an end. He hates to see boys from his town die in war, but, he reasons, “It may be necessary to use up the lives of young men . . . . A choice has to be made between terrible sacrifice and terrible defeat.”
Other characters and circumstances show that death can be a price worth paying for a greater good. Sometimes the lesson somes out symbolically, even allegorically. Uncle Stanley Gibbs digs graves among his other duties at the church. Or has dug them until lately. He can still use the shovel but finds it hard these days to move his old knees enough to get out of the hole once he digs it. The effects of impending death take away his livelihood and literally put him in an early grave. So he asks Jayber Crow, a character who has thought he has no purpose, to take over that part of his job. Jayber finds that for the first time he has a plan, that he possesses “not only a life, but a death.” And Uncle Stanley, now more appreciative than ever of the job he almost lost, discovers that what he gave up has come back. “It is a resurrection. He thought he was a goner, but now his life is twice as abundant as before.”
The novel is told in the present tense, and this, too, plays a symbolic role in the book’s lesson of life, death, and resurrection, of loss and hope. Virgil Feltner has been reported missing in action. The narrator tells us: “The news has gone its rounds among the gathering places, and has quietly set the young man’s life into the past tense of the town’s consciousness. . . . To speak of him in the present tense becomes the private observance of his family.” Burley Coulter expands on the notion of family observance of death in a letter to his nephew Nat, also away at war: “We don’t rest in peace. The life of a good man who has died belongs to the people who cared about him.” Put it all together, and it seems to say that Wendell Berry sees his characters as virtual family and cares about them too much to speak of them in the past tense. I reported a few days ago that I sensed constant hope in the book, and now I see why.
Rain also pervades A Place on Earth. Like death, it hinders people’s movements. It tests their patience. It tests their works (as when young Virgil plows his first field incorrectly). And the connection between rain and death solidifies when a flash flood caused by the inexorable rain carries away a young girl. And so these parallels reinforce the view that death, just like rain, is both bad and good. The rain that caused the river to rise also brings new life out of the fields each spring. And the same death that puts lost soldiers into the past tense brings resurrection.
Thursday, June 6, 2013
A Place on Earth
As I reported in the last post, I have given up on my plan to read two Faulkner novels this year. Already way ahead on my schedule, I had plenty of time to try some things off the list, so I started A Place on Earth by Wendell Berry. I found out about Berry a couple of years ago in my continuing search for Christian authors in the twentieth century. My prejudice may be ill-founded, but most recent Christian fiction seems more like pulp than literature; at least the covers make it look that way. And I keep thinking that surely some Christian in the last fifty years has done something like Lewis or Waugh or Greene. So every few months I Google it again to see what I can find.
So far Berry satisfies my itch. He writes poetic prose, and the Christianity comes through clearly without sounding forced. Oddly, the book reminds me a lot of Faulkner: a small town and its group of families with long intertwining histories; carefully worded, vivid descriptions of things, thoughts, and feelings; characters haunted by the past; various kinds of veils of mystery for the reader to get lost in. Reading about Berry a couple of days ago, I found out that all his novels tell stories of the same town, with timeframes reaching back to the nineteenth century; so Faulkner’s shadow surely does hover behind Berry’s figure. And yet I come away from Berry with a hope I don’t usually get from Faulkner. If they both talk to me incessantly about the painful sore on my soul, at least Berry does so while putting some balm on it. This spring anyway, I felt judgment from Faulkner, while so far from Berry I sense commiseration.
Every character in the novel has a backstory of pain and death to deal with. There’s Frank Lathrop, who watches after the shop of his son Jasper, who has gone to war – watching not consisting of running the store but rather of meeting friends in its back room for a regular game of rummy. There’s the lame carpenter, Ernest Finley, who finds his shop gradually arranged so as to require the least amount of walking possible. There’s Uncle Stanley Gibbs, who has lost his hearing and answers everyone’s first greeting as if it were a question about his health (it rarely is). There’s Jayber Crow, who thinks because he was adopted that his life was begun without a purpose, and thinks because his life was begun without purpose that he can never find any later in life, either. There’s Burley Coulter who raises his nephews after their mother dies and their father abandons them, only to see one of them killed in the war. And there’s Nat, the surviving nephew, who has to live with the loss of mother, father, and brother. The narration tells us that these events and circumstances shape each person and that among the losses one must learn to accept is the loss of the person he would have been had life gone differently.
Whatever Berry's brand of Christianity is, it doesn’t offer easy, ready-made answers. In fact, the characters merely tolerate the preacher when he comes to offer condolences after a son is lost in war, because the preacher’s words don’t recognize the unique circumstances of the personalities involved. Instead, the grieving townsfolk think of him as merely offering a set speech with blanks filled in by names meaningless to him. Talk of the Hereafter brings no solace to a creature who cannot find a place on earth. And that place has to accommodate loss and the individuality loss shapes in each of us.
So far Berry satisfies my itch. He writes poetic prose, and the Christianity comes through clearly without sounding forced. Oddly, the book reminds me a lot of Faulkner: a small town and its group of families with long intertwining histories; carefully worded, vivid descriptions of things, thoughts, and feelings; characters haunted by the past; various kinds of veils of mystery for the reader to get lost in. Reading about Berry a couple of days ago, I found out that all his novels tell stories of the same town, with timeframes reaching back to the nineteenth century; so Faulkner’s shadow surely does hover behind Berry’s figure. And yet I come away from Berry with a hope I don’t usually get from Faulkner. If they both talk to me incessantly about the painful sore on my soul, at least Berry does so while putting some balm on it. This spring anyway, I felt judgment from Faulkner, while so far from Berry I sense commiseration.
Every character in the novel has a backstory of pain and death to deal with. There’s Frank Lathrop, who watches after the shop of his son Jasper, who has gone to war – watching not consisting of running the store but rather of meeting friends in its back room for a regular game of rummy. There’s the lame carpenter, Ernest Finley, who finds his shop gradually arranged so as to require the least amount of walking possible. There’s Uncle Stanley Gibbs, who has lost his hearing and answers everyone’s first greeting as if it were a question about his health (it rarely is). There’s Jayber Crow, who thinks because he was adopted that his life was begun without a purpose, and thinks because his life was begun without purpose that he can never find any later in life, either. There’s Burley Coulter who raises his nephews after their mother dies and their father abandons them, only to see one of them killed in the war. And there’s Nat, the surviving nephew, who has to live with the loss of mother, father, and brother. The narration tells us that these events and circumstances shape each person and that among the losses one must learn to accept is the loss of the person he would have been had life gone differently.
Whatever Berry's brand of Christianity is, it doesn’t offer easy, ready-made answers. In fact, the characters merely tolerate the preacher when he comes to offer condolences after a son is lost in war, because the preacher’s words don’t recognize the unique circumstances of the personalities involved. Instead, the grieving townsfolk think of him as merely offering a set speech with blanks filled in by names meaningless to him. Talk of the Hereafter brings no solace to a creature who cannot find a place on earth. And that place has to accommodate loss and the individuality loss shapes in each of us.
Monday, June 3, 2013
Co-authoring
German composer Paul Hindemith once explained that he saw music listeners as co-composers. A listener encountering a piece for the first time but knowledgeable of its style hears both the actual piece, Hindemith says, and the piece that he expects to hear moment-by-moment. Listening to a passage, this engaged audience member thinks (in a manner of speaking), “Yes: up, and up, and up, and then up some mo— oops, it actually went down there.” In this way the savvy listener sits in spirit at Hindemith’s elbow, composing along with him a parallel piece, similar to the original but, if Hindemith knows what he’s doing, not as good.
When I read, I experience not just two but several parallel streams of ideas. I hear the words (some people don’t – those would be the people who can read faster than a snail’s pace). I see pictures of the people and events. I think of the ideas being expressed. I ask myself “What happens next?” and “How does this fit in?” and “What does the countess want with a torn workman’s glove?” I start to think of my old gloves, and the lawn which needs mowing. I wonder if I’ll have enough money to pay to have the lawn mowed this summer. I think of more lucrative careers I could have had. I come back and reread p. 213.
Sometimes the parallel streams sound something like, “I can’t stop now. Maybe just one more page, and then I’ll get up to take care of the yard. Or three more pages: that will get me to the end of the chapter. Oh, the next chapter’s not very long, either. Maybe the yard can wait.” Sometimes I deal with thoughts saying, “Oh, no! I don’t remember this character (or term or object) at all. Should I go back and find her? Or should I just keep going and hope it al becomes clear in a page or two?”
Sometimes, when the book and I don’t get along so well, the prose I compose to go along with it says something more along these lines: “I don’t remember this character, and I don’t seem to care. Maybe if I just plow ahead, I can get through the book by tomorrow. As a guy I think I got the main point.” As a guy with a ten-year reading Plan, I’m used to plowing, and I’m pretty good at it.
But two days ago, I actually gave up on a book. I left unfinished only two books from the first decade of reading, and I hadn’t dropped or even shortened anything from the second. But six-and-a-half years into it, I stopped Failkner’s Absalom, Absalom! 16% of the way through. I’m not totally sure why. If I have enough reading discipline to have a ten-year book plan, why didn’t I have enough discipline to get through this one novel? I’ve read some Faulkner before that I really enjoyed (The Unvanquished, The Sound and the Fury) and some that I was oddly fascinated by (As I Lay Dying). Maybe it’s that I read another Faulkner novel just two months ago. Maybe it’s that the theme of this one seemed to be exactly the same as that of Light in August: people haunted by stories ancestors have told of ancestors from before the Civil War. Maybe it’s summer and I just wasn’t in the mood for sentences a page-and-a-half-long.
I originally only had room for one Faulkner novel on my list; I just didn’t know which one I would read until last year, when I found strong reviews of two different ones. So I don’t feel I’ve betrayed myself too badly. After all, I only gave up on my decision to go above and beyond. I’m still right on track.
A parallel track, I’m sure.
When I read, I experience not just two but several parallel streams of ideas. I hear the words (some people don’t – those would be the people who can read faster than a snail’s pace). I see pictures of the people and events. I think of the ideas being expressed. I ask myself “What happens next?” and “How does this fit in?” and “What does the countess want with a torn workman’s glove?” I start to think of my old gloves, and the lawn which needs mowing. I wonder if I’ll have enough money to pay to have the lawn mowed this summer. I think of more lucrative careers I could have had. I come back and reread p. 213.
Sometimes the parallel streams sound something like, “I can’t stop now. Maybe just one more page, and then I’ll get up to take care of the yard. Or three more pages: that will get me to the end of the chapter. Oh, the next chapter’s not very long, either. Maybe the yard can wait.” Sometimes I deal with thoughts saying, “Oh, no! I don’t remember this character (or term or object) at all. Should I go back and find her? Or should I just keep going and hope it al becomes clear in a page or two?”
Sometimes, when the book and I don’t get along so well, the prose I compose to go along with it says something more along these lines: “I don’t remember this character, and I don’t seem to care. Maybe if I just plow ahead, I can get through the book by tomorrow. As a guy I think I got the main point.” As a guy with a ten-year reading Plan, I’m used to plowing, and I’m pretty good at it.
But two days ago, I actually gave up on a book. I left unfinished only two books from the first decade of reading, and I hadn’t dropped or even shortened anything from the second. But six-and-a-half years into it, I stopped Failkner’s Absalom, Absalom! 16% of the way through. I’m not totally sure why. If I have enough reading discipline to have a ten-year book plan, why didn’t I have enough discipline to get through this one novel? I’ve read some Faulkner before that I really enjoyed (The Unvanquished, The Sound and the Fury) and some that I was oddly fascinated by (As I Lay Dying). Maybe it’s that I read another Faulkner novel just two months ago. Maybe it’s that the theme of this one seemed to be exactly the same as that of Light in August: people haunted by stories ancestors have told of ancestors from before the Civil War. Maybe it’s summer and I just wasn’t in the mood for sentences a page-and-a-half-long.
I originally only had room for one Faulkner novel on my list; I just didn’t know which one I would read until last year, when I found strong reviews of two different ones. So I don’t feel I’ve betrayed myself too badly. After all, I only gave up on my decision to go above and beyond. I’m still right on track.
A parallel track, I’m sure.
Sunday, May 26, 2013
Sonnet 65
My post on Shelley’s “A Summer Evening Churchyard” has received more views than any other post from the last four months. I never know what makes one post more interesting than others to internet surfers, but I can’t help but think that the popularity of that particular post is due to the current general ignorance of poetry in our society. I know I went through twelve years of public school with very little study of poetry and no instruction on ways to appreciate the beauty of its music. I started learning about poetry only in my senior year of college. I’ve continued to pick up ideas here and there, but have only gained any real confidence with poetry in the last six or eight years. I hope that with my post from February, I’ve helped some homeschoolers or lifelong learners gain a little understanding of that bit of lovely language.
Here’s a short list of the milestones in my journey of poetic discovery:
• Jack Gilbert, “Poetry is a kind of lying” – The first line of the poem announces the main point: poetry is not to be taken literally. But keep reading! Poetry nevertheless tells the truth.
• G. K. Chesterton, “Sound and Sense in Poetry,” Illustrated London News, May 30, 1931 – Chesterton uncovers a world in the analysis of one line of poetry.
• William Mouser, Walking in Wisdom ($403.47 new on Amazon?!?!) – This brilliant little book made the biblical Proverbs fifty times more interesting to me than they were before. Among its treasures is a section on figures of speech that explained to me what my high school English teachers should have.
• Laurence Perrine, Sound and Sense – I feel like I earned a minor in poetry by going through this excellent guide.
• Carper and Attridge, Meter and Meaning – The best explanation of poetic meter and scansion I’ve found.
I hope that list proves helpful. I’ve been putting off writing in detail about a Shakespeare sonnet, concerned that I’m not up to the task. So I wrote a few days ago about one aspect of the poems without getting into any actual poetry. And today I wrote a long introduction to delay even further the moment of truth. And now I’m writing an explanation of the delay tactic in order to delay yet more. One last delay: here’s the poem itself that I’ll have a couple of things to say about momentarily . . .
But then the defensive power suddenly diminished: least powerful of all against the ravages of death is the beauty of a human form and face. The words Shakespeare associates with beauty contrast poignantly with those he uses to describe time and mortality. Beauty gets “flower” and “summer” and “honey” and “jewel.” There’s not a hard stopped consonant in any of those words; they are sweet both in sound and in sense. Time on the other hand gets the k’s and t’s of fierce words like “wrackful” and “decay” and “batt’ring” and “swift foot.”
And now, a last point that may sound a little crazy. Many music theorists have at least a mild fascination with the Golden Section, a division into two parts of some length in such a way that the ratio of the smaller part to the larger is the same as the ratio of the larger part to the whole. Mathematicians would probably point out the error in my explanation, since that“ratio” involves one ir-ratio-nal number, a number very close to but not exactly equal to .618. Divide a mile into two parts: the first part .618 of a mile long, and the second .382 of a mile long (the amount left over when you subtract .618 from 1). The ratio of the smaller part to the larger is also approximately .618. (Try it!) Many ancient Greek sculptures and buildings display this ratio. Musicians get interested when they find an especially pleasing piece has its climax 61.8% of the way through. (Disney’s Donald Duck in Mathmagic Land gives the best possible explanation and visual demonstration of the Golden Section.)
It occurs to me that English-sonnet form might take advantage of the Golden Section. Many of the sonnets take some sort of turn after eight lines. Our sonnet today interrupts itself with the exclamation “O fearful meditation!” after its eighth line. Any sonnet has fourteen lines, and 8 divided by 14 is approximately.57143, a little low for the Golden Section. The last six lines, though, also have a dividing point: after four lines, the alternating rhyme scheme is replaced by a couplet that renders the culminating point of the poem. The ratio of 4 to 6 is approximately .6667, a little high for the Golden Section. But average the two, and you get .619, close enough to allow any power this time-honored mathematical relationship might actually have to work on our psyches.
Update from six years later: Divide the poem after "O fearful meditation!" That makes the first part 8.7 lines long, and 8.7 divided by 14 is approximately .6214, as close as you can get to the Golden Section in a poem of exactly one-hundred-forty syllables. Now consider the remaining part of 5.3 lines. The final couplet starts after 3.3 of those 5.3, and 3.3 divided by 5.3 is approximately .6226: again, as close you can come in splitting up 53 syllables!
Here’s a short list of the milestones in my journey of poetic discovery:
• Jack Gilbert, “Poetry is a kind of lying” – The first line of the poem announces the main point: poetry is not to be taken literally. But keep reading! Poetry nevertheless tells the truth.
• G. K. Chesterton, “Sound and Sense in Poetry,” Illustrated London News, May 30, 1931 – Chesterton uncovers a world in the analysis of one line of poetry.
• William Mouser, Walking in Wisdom ($403.47 new on Amazon?!?!) – This brilliant little book made the biblical Proverbs fifty times more interesting to me than they were before. Among its treasures is a section on figures of speech that explained to me what my high school English teachers should have.
• Laurence Perrine, Sound and Sense – I feel like I earned a minor in poetry by going through this excellent guide.
• Carper and Attridge, Meter and Meaning – The best explanation of poetic meter and scansion I’ve found.
I hope that list proves helpful. I’ve been putting off writing in detail about a Shakespeare sonnet, concerned that I’m not up to the task. So I wrote a few days ago about one aspect of the poems without getting into any actual poetry. And today I wrote a long introduction to delay even further the moment of truth. And now I’m writing an explanation of the delay tactic in order to delay yet more. One last delay: here’s the poem itself that I’ll have a couple of things to say about momentarily . . .
Shakespeare, Sonnet 65The first clause is a bit odd: it seems to lack a verb. But who wants to begrudge the Bard a dull and lifeless “There is”? In any case, there is no piece of brass, nor stone, nor plot of earth, nor ocean that does not eventually meet with decay and dissolution. As with most lists in good poetry, this one has an intesifying progression: each item in the list is larger than the last, each death a little harder to believe. I can easily imagine a brass gewgaw in the trash heap, but the death of the Pacific Ocean? Unfathomable. (I’m groaning, too.)
Since brass, nor stone, nor earth, nor boundless sea,
But sad mortality o'ersways their power,
How with this rage shall beauty hold a plea,
Whose action is no stronger than a flower?
O how shall summer’s honey breath hold out
Against the wrackful siege of batt'ring days,
When rocks impregnable are not so stout,
Nor gates of steel so strong but time decays?
O fearful meditation! Where, alack,
Shall time’s best jewel from time’s chest lie hid?
Or what strong hand can hold his swift foot back?
Or who his spoil or beauty can forbid?
O none, unless this miracle have might,
That in black ink my love may still shine bright.
But then the defensive power suddenly diminished: least powerful of all against the ravages of death is the beauty of a human form and face. The words Shakespeare associates with beauty contrast poignantly with those he uses to describe time and mortality. Beauty gets “flower” and “summer” and “honey” and “jewel.” There’s not a hard stopped consonant in any of those words; they are sweet both in sound and in sense. Time on the other hand gets the k’s and t’s of fierce words like “wrackful” and “decay” and “batt’ring” and “swift foot.”
And now, a last point that may sound a little crazy. Many music theorists have at least a mild fascination with the Golden Section, a division into two parts of some length in such a way that the ratio of the smaller part to the larger is the same as the ratio of the larger part to the whole. Mathematicians would probably point out the error in my explanation, since that“ratio” involves one ir-ratio-nal number, a number very close to but not exactly equal to .618. Divide a mile into two parts: the first part .618 of a mile long, and the second .382 of a mile long (the amount left over when you subtract .618 from 1). The ratio of the smaller part to the larger is also approximately .618. (Try it!) Many ancient Greek sculptures and buildings display this ratio. Musicians get interested when they find an especially pleasing piece has its climax 61.8% of the way through. (Disney’s Donald Duck in Mathmagic Land gives the best possible explanation and visual demonstration of the Golden Section.)
It occurs to me that English-sonnet form might take advantage of the Golden Section. Many of the sonnets take some sort of turn after eight lines. Our sonnet today interrupts itself with the exclamation “O fearful meditation!” after its eighth line. Any sonnet has fourteen lines, and 8 divided by 14 is approximately.57143, a little low for the Golden Section. The last six lines, though, also have a dividing point: after four lines, the alternating rhyme scheme is replaced by a couplet that renders the culminating point of the poem. The ratio of 4 to 6 is approximately .6667, a little high for the Golden Section. But average the two, and you get .619, close enough to allow any power this time-honored mathematical relationship might actually have to work on our psyches.
Update from six years later: Divide the poem after "O fearful meditation!" That makes the first part 8.7 lines long, and 8.7 divided by 14 is approximately .6214, as close as you can get to the Golden Section in a poem of exactly one-hundred-forty syllables. Now consider the remaining part of 5.3 lines. The final couplet starts after 3.3 of those 5.3, and 3.3 divided by 5.3 is approximately .6226: again, as close you can come in splitting up 53 syllables!
Labels:
Carper and Attridge,
G. K. Chesterton,
Jack Gilbert,
Laurence Perrine,
William Mouser,
William Shakespeare
Thursday, May 23, 2013
What Does Shakespeare Mean?
I admit that it’s a little unnerving. In any case, I can’t read Shakespeare’s sonnets without noticing and feeling distracted by the fact. Yes, the first 126 of them are addressed to a beautiful young man. Many scholars and critics have published their speculations about who the fair youth is, as if assuming that he is a real, particular person, and not a character. And of course, there is much speculation as to Shakespeare’s sexual preferences in light of these poems. What does it mean?
It certainly could mean that Shakespeare had homosexual desires for a young man. Such things happen. But the young man of the poems could be a character. Or the “I” of the poems could be a character. I remember watching an episode of The Andy Griffith Show in which Andy sits on the front porch and sings “Black, Black, Black Is the Color of My True Love’s Hair,” the “true love” in the song being explicitly a “he.” And I remember concluding, not that the actual man Andy Griffith was a homosexual, not that the character Andy Taylor was a homosexual, but that “Black, Black, Black” is such a beautiful song, it would be a shame if half the human race were barred from singing it.
Or it could mean that “love” doesn’t always refer to sex. I know that’s hard to believe in our day and society, but some cultures have held such a view. Maybe Shakespeare or his poetic persona truly admired the beauty of a young man without that love involving any intimate desires. In fact, several of the sonnets urge the man to find a wife and pass on his dazzling beauty to a new generation.
But, as I said, the issue feels like a distraction. Shakespeare’s sonnets mean so much more. They mean, My love for you is so great that the words “I love you” are not adequate. They mean, Time may win over beauty every time, but I still prefer beauty. And they certainly mean, I have found some gorgeous language and I want to share it with the world.
It certainly could mean that Shakespeare had homosexual desires for a young man. Such things happen. But the young man of the poems could be a character. Or the “I” of the poems could be a character. I remember watching an episode of The Andy Griffith Show in which Andy sits on the front porch and sings “Black, Black, Black Is the Color of My True Love’s Hair,” the “true love” in the song being explicitly a “he.” And I remember concluding, not that the actual man Andy Griffith was a homosexual, not that the character Andy Taylor was a homosexual, but that “Black, Black, Black” is such a beautiful song, it would be a shame if half the human race were barred from singing it.
Or it could mean that “love” doesn’t always refer to sex. I know that’s hard to believe in our day and society, but some cultures have held such a view. Maybe Shakespeare or his poetic persona truly admired the beauty of a young man without that love involving any intimate desires. In fact, several of the sonnets urge the man to find a wife and pass on his dazzling beauty to a new generation.
But, as I said, the issue feels like a distraction. Shakespeare’s sonnets mean so much more. They mean, My love for you is so great that the words “I love you” are not adequate. They mean, Time may win over beauty every time, but I still prefer beauty. And they certainly mean, I have found some gorgeous language and I want to share it with the world.
Sunday, May 19, 2013
Another Happy Day with Algebra
Every once in a great while I actually check the feed on facebook. When I do, I always see a lot of joyous or funny things that I enjoy. But I also usually see at least one thing that sticks in my craw. About a month ago, as I was smiling at pictures of kids and silly jokes and announcements of various blessed milestones in friends’ lives, the post that burst my bubble of joy came from a former graduate student. It read, “Well, another day has passed and I didn’t use algebra once.” My immediate response was, “Why not?!”
My student, of course, meant it as a dig at time she thought her high school had wasted, but I saw it only as a sad commentary on herself. High schools waste countless hours of teenagers’ time, I agree. But the time spent teaching algebra is not among the wasted hours. I don’t know if Paul Simon would agree, but algebra is not part of the crap. If my student spends day after day without using it, I can only say that she’s the poorer for it.
I use algebra almost every day of my life. I compare prices. I estimate fuel costs. I’ve enjoyed programming little computer games for about thirty years now, and the code to determine scores or the placement of objects on the screen consists of nothing but algebra. And of course I calculate grades, estimate grades, average grades, figure the minimum grade a panicked student needs on the final to get an A or a C. (Hardly any student worries about getting a B instead of a C.) I use algebra all the time.
But why should I even accept the terms of this silly quip? Why assume algebra is to be used, like a tissue you throw away once you blow your nose with it? To see that an algebraic equation works is to put into action that part of ourselves which was created in the image of God, and thus to see into God’s mind. And the vision of God is happiness.
Why do A? In order to do B. Why do B? In order to do C. But why do C? Aristotle points out that if this search for reasons has no end, I’ll never do A in the first place. There must exist some goal, he reasons, about which we do not ask, Why? And that goal is happiness. I do algebra because it brings me happiness.
I just finished book VIII of Euclid’s Elements yesterday, and I was surprised to see that, like the two or three chapters just before, it leaves rigorous geometry aside for a while longer to continue with number theory and algebra. At least, I can turn it into something that looks more like algebra to me. I wish I knew more about the history of mathematics. I wish I knew for sure whether Euclid could conceive of ratios (comparisons of whole numbers) as fractions (parts of units). And I wish I knew if algebra proper depends on the concept of fractions. But what I do know is that if I turn Euclid’s prose into algebraical symbols and use fractions to represent his ratios, things start to make sense to me.
For instance, one of the main points of book VIII is that between any two square numbers, say A and B, lies exactly one number C (one whole number, not a fraction or irrational number) such that C/A = B/C. And that number is found by multiplying the square roots of the two original numbers. As an example, take 4 (2 squared) and 9 (3 squared). Multiply 2 x 3 to get 6. And, sure enough, 6/4 equals 9/6. I hope I expressed it clearly; it’s clear to me, at least. But here’s part of Euclid’s proof:
My student, of course, meant it as a dig at time she thought her high school had wasted, but I saw it only as a sad commentary on herself. High schools waste countless hours of teenagers’ time, I agree. But the time spent teaching algebra is not among the wasted hours. I don’t know if Paul Simon would agree, but algebra is not part of the crap. If my student spends day after day without using it, I can only say that she’s the poorer for it.
I use algebra almost every day of my life. I compare prices. I estimate fuel costs. I’ve enjoyed programming little computer games for about thirty years now, and the code to determine scores or the placement of objects on the screen consists of nothing but algebra. And of course I calculate grades, estimate grades, average grades, figure the minimum grade a panicked student needs on the final to get an A or a C. (Hardly any student worries about getting a B instead of a C.) I use algebra all the time.
But why should I even accept the terms of this silly quip? Why assume algebra is to be used, like a tissue you throw away once you blow your nose with it? To see that an algebraic equation works is to put into action that part of ourselves which was created in the image of God, and thus to see into God’s mind. And the vision of God is happiness.
Why do A? In order to do B. Why do B? In order to do C. But why do C? Aristotle points out that if this search for reasons has no end, I’ll never do A in the first place. There must exist some goal, he reasons, about which we do not ask, Why? And that goal is happiness. I do algebra because it brings me happiness.
I just finished book VIII of Euclid’s Elements yesterday, and I was surprised to see that, like the two or three chapters just before, it leaves rigorous geometry aside for a while longer to continue with number theory and algebra. At least, I can turn it into something that looks more like algebra to me. I wish I knew more about the history of mathematics. I wish I knew for sure whether Euclid could conceive of ratios (comparisons of whole numbers) as fractions (parts of units). And I wish I knew if algebra proper depends on the concept of fractions. But what I do know is that if I turn Euclid’s prose into algebraical symbols and use fractions to represent his ratios, things start to make sense to me.
For instance, one of the main points of book VIII is that between any two square numbers, say A and B, lies exactly one number C (one whole number, not a fraction or irrational number) such that C/A = B/C. And that number is found by multiplying the square roots of the two original numbers. As an example, take 4 (2 squared) and 9 (3 squared). Multiply 2 x 3 to get 6. And, sure enough, 6/4 equals 9/6. I hope I expressed it clearly; it’s clear to me, at least. But here’s part of Euclid’s proof:
Let A, B be square numbers, and let C be the side of A, and D of B. . . . Let C by multiplying D make E. Now since A is a square and C is its side, therefore C by multiplying itself has made A. For the same reason also, D by multiplying itself has made B. Since, then, C by multiplying the numbers C, D has made A, E respectively, therefore, as C is to D, so is A to E.And it goes on. In a geometrical proof with the handy diagram and its labeled points, I can usually follow Euclid’s prose. But in these algebraical sections, I get lost easily. So I translated some of the proofs of book VIII into terminology more familiar to me in order to see their methods and conclusions more clearly. This one could look something like this:
Given c • c = a, d • d = b, find e such that e/a = b/e.Reverse demonstration, or check proof, after e has been found:
1. e/a = b/e (Given)
2. e = (b • a)/e (Multiply both sides by a)
3. e • e = b • a (Multiply both sides by e)
4. e • e = d • d • c • c (3: Substitution with given facts concerning a and b.)
5. e • e = d • c • d • c (Commutative property of multiplication)
6. e • e = (d • c) • (d • c) (Associative property of multiplication)
7. e = d • c (Take the square root of both sides.)
1. e/a = b/e (Given)I know, I know. I paid attention forty years ago as almost none of my classmates did. But now, thanks to eighth-grade algebra class and Euclid, I see something I didn’t see before, and it brings me happiness.
2. a = c • c (Given)
3. b = d • d (Given)
4. e = d • c (Found above)
5. (d • c) / (c • c) = (d • d) / (d • c) (1, substituting 2, 3, and 4)
6. d / c = (d • d) / (d • c) (Reduce left fraction)
7. d / c = d / c (Reduce right fraction)
Subscribe to:
Posts (Atom)